Archives par mot-clé : Serâ Tokay

Les femmes chefs d’orchestre – Women on the podium

Les femmes chefs d’orchestre – Women on the podium

Josephine Weinlich & Europäischen Damenorchestra - 1873
Josephine Weinlich & Europäischen Damenorchester – 1873
Mélomanes misogynes de tout poil, il faudra vous y faire : on va finir par voir un nombre croissant de femmes chefs d’orchestre : il a déjà fallu que vous vous habituiez à en voir un nombre croissant au sein de l’orchestre (même aux cuivres !) – on se rappelle de la polémique lors du rejet par vote en 1983 de la clarinettiste Sabine Meyer par les Berliner philharmoniker après sa période probatoire : 73 contre, 4 pour… – Sans remonter à Fanny, la sœur de Félix Mendelssohn, on ne sait plus qu’il y eut de nombreux chefs d’orchestre féminins de la fin du 19e siècle à la 2e Guerre mondiale, en général à la tête d’orchestres entièrement féminins dans les années 20 / 30, à l’existence souvent bien éphémère.

 
À notre supposé mélomane misogyne, qu’en sera-t-il si, par extraordinaire, l’une d’entre elles vient à diriger en jupe ! Eh bien çà existe avec Silvia Sanz Torre dont je n’ai pas la date de naissance…
jupe
Misogynists music lover, you will have to keep with that: a growing number of women conductors: you have been unfortunate to see a growing number of women within the orchestra (even with coppers!) – one remembers the polemic at the time of the rejection by vote of the clarinetist Sabine Meyer in1983  by Berliner philharmoniker after her probationary period: 73 against, 4 for… -Without going back to Fanny, Felix Mendelssohn’s sister, one does not know any more that there were many female conductors from the end of the 19th century to the 2nd World war, in general at the head of entirely female orchestras in the 20/30′

Two young feminine conductors that we know a little: Susanna Mälkki, leader of the Ensemble Intercontemporain, who impressed us in two discs of contemporary music (Manoury & Mantovani).

And Serâ Tokay, who has just given us an interview; she had just founded her chamber orchestra, « Philharmonie de Chambre Lutèce »; she impressed us in the two chamber symphonies by Schoenberg in Paris, some months ago.

To our supposed misogynist music lover, what about, if by extraordinary, a woman conducts the orchestra dressed in a skirt… Well,  Silvia Sanz Torre did it!

Some conductors are missing, since I could not get their birth date, even some wouldn’t give it to me… See also this list.

Chiquinha Gonzaga (1847-1935) [BR]  gonzaga
Elisabeth Kuyper (1877-1953) [GB]  kuyper
Ethel Leginska (1886-1953) [GB]  leginska
Antonia Brico (1886-1989) [GB]  brico
Nadia Boulanger (1887-1979) [FR]  boulanger
Jane Evrard (1893-1984) |FR]  evrard
Frédérique Petrides (1903-1983) [GB] petrides
Avril Coleridge-Taylor (1903-1998) [GB] coleridge
Natalia Sats (1903-1993) [RU] sats
Frieda Belinfante (1904-1995) [NL]  belifante
Imogen Holst (1907-1984) [GB]  holst
Blanche Honegger Moyse (1909-2011) [GB]  honegger-moise
Vítězslava Kaprálová (1915-1940) [CZ]  kapralova
Sarah Caldwell (1924-2006) [GB] caldwell
Eve Queler (1931*) [US]  queler

Janet Canetty-Clarke

(1935*) [GB]  clarke
Sylvia Caduff (1937*) [CH]  caduff
Tania León (1943*) [CU]  leon
Catherine Comet (1944*) [FR]  comet
Claire Gibault (1945*) [FR]  gibaut
Liana Issakadze (1946*) [GE]  issakadze
Chiara Banchini (1946*) [CH]  bianchini
Agnieszka Kreiner-Bogdańska (1947*) [PL]  kreiner
Lorraine Vaillancourt (1947*) [CA]  vaillancourt
Jeanne Lamon (1949*) [US]  lamon
Jane Glover (1949*) [GB]  glover
Odaline de la Martinez (1949*) [US]  delamartinez
Iona Brown (1954*) [GB]  brown
JoAnn Falletta (1954*) [US]  faletta
Marin Alsop (1956*) [GB]  alsop
Wasfi Kani (1956*) [GB]  kani
Gisèle Ban-Dor (1955*) [GB]  ben-dor
Marie-Jeanne Dufour (1955*) [CH]  dufour
Romely Pfund (1955*) [GE]  pfund
Sian Edwards (1959*) [GB]  edwards
Yip Wing-sie (1960*) [HK]  wing-sie
Julia Jones (1961*) [GB]  jones
Erica Muhl (1961*) [US] mulh
Silvia Massarelli (1961*) [IT] massarelli
Simone Young (1961*) [AU]  young
Laurence Equilbey (1962*) [FR]  equilbey
Luisa Russo (1962*) [IT] russo
Véronique Lacroix (1963*) [CA] lacroix
Andrea Quinn (1964*) [GB]  quinn
Graziella Contratto (1966*) [CH]  contratto
Natalia Luis-Bassa (1966*) [VE]  luis-bassa
Kori-Lynn Wilson (1967*) [CA]  wilson
Emmanuelle Haïm (1967*) [FR]  haim
Susanna Mälkki (1969*) [FI]  malki
Karen Kamensek (1970*) [US]  kamensek
Tomomi Nishimoto (1970*) [JP]  nishimoto
Anu Tali (1972*) [EE]  tali
Sarah Ioannides (1972*) [GR] ioannides
Inma Shara (1972*) [SP] shara
Hiba Kawas (1972*) [LB]  kawas
Kanako Abe (1973*) [FR]  abe
Xian Zhang (1973*) [CN]  zhang
Elizabeth Askren (1973*) [US]  askren
Joana Carneiro (1976*) [PT]  carneiro
Sofi Jeannin (1976*) [SE]  jeannin
Carolyn Kuan (1978*) [US] kuan
Zahia Ziouani (1977*) [FR] ziouani
Alondra de la Parra (1980*) [ME]  delaparra
Ariane Matiakh (1980*) [FR]  matiakh
Nvart Andreassian (1980*) [TU]  andreassian
Nazanin Aghakani (1980*) [AU]  aghakani
Dalia Stasevska (1985*) [FI]  stasevska 
Migra Gražinytė-Tyla (1986*) [LH] Mirga Gražinytė-Tyla

 

  From the New Yorker, an interesting interview : »A formidable figure in Russian music, Temirkanov served as a mentor both to Gergiev and later to Petrenko. The interviewer, the Paris-based pianist and composer Elena Gantchikova, deserves credit for grilling him. A Russian-speaking friend provided this translation:Q.: In your opinion, could a woman conduct?
A.: In my view, no.
Q.: Why not?!
A.: I don’t know if it’s God’s will, or nature’s, that women give birth and men do not. That’s something that no one takes offense at. But if you say that a women can’t conduct, then everyone’s offended. As Marx said, in response to the question “What’s your favorite virtue in a woman?”—“Weakness.” And this is correct. The important thing is, a woman should be beautiful, likable, attractive. Musicians will look at her and be distracted from the music!
Q.: Why? There are women in the orchestra; people indifferent to a women’s charms. Besides, how many times would you be enraptured by appearances? After all, it’s something you tire of, and switch to the heart of the question. Statistically, of course, there are women conductors.
A.: Yes, they do exist.
Q.: Nevertheless, you maintain that these are less than women, or less than conductors.
A.: No, simply that in my opinion, it’s counter to nature.
Q.: And what is it in the conductor’s profession that runs counter to a woman’s nature? That’s counter to the essence of the conductor’s profession?
A.: The essence of the conductor’s profession is strength. The essence of a woman is weakness. »


From Artsjournal.com, an other intersting point of view by :

Jorma Panula has been the most successful spotter and trainer of conductors for the past 30 years. His pupils include Esa-Pekka Salonen and at least 20 others who hold international posts.

Q: Do you think it is good that women enter the profession and become conductors?

JP: No! What the hell, we have men already. It is such a limited profession… They can try, but it is a completely different deal. I can’t comment on media or public opinion. But women… Of course they are trying! Some of them are making faces, sweating and fussing, but it is not getting any better – only worse! They can come [to my masterclasses] and try. It’s not a problem – if they choose the right pieces. If they take more feminine music. Bruckner or Stravinsky will not do, but Debussy is OK. This is a purely biological question.

Panula’s comments have provoked outrage in Finland. Salonen has tweeted (in Finnish): ‘Conducting is about skill, not biology. There is no reason why women cannot do it equally well or better.’

Schoenberg par Rattle à Berlin

Schoenberg par Rattle à Berlin

 

Sir Simon Rattle revient à Schoenberg dans un programme pour grand orchestre et propose 3 facettes du compositeur : le transcripteur, dans la version orchestrale du quatuor n°1 pour piano de Brahms (1937), le compositeur à la fois atonal et sériel dans la musique  d’accompagnement pour un scène de film  (1929–1930) et enfin la version pour grand orchestre (1935) de la première symphonie de chambre (1906).

Si l’on peut regretter la pâte sonore de l’orchestre d’avant les ères Abbado & Rattle, on appréciera néanmoins cette lecture d’une transcription qui fait parfois penser à celles de Stokowsky ! La musique de film (« Danger imminent », « Peur panique », « Catastrophe »…) est très intéressante avec de belles (atonales donc…) atmosphères. La symphonie de chambre peut être nettement préférée dans sa version initiale (comme lors d’un concert il y a quelques mois par la talentueuse chef d’origine turque, Serâ Tokay).

Rappelons une version inégalée des Cinq pièces pour orchestre op. 16 par Kubelík.